Jerome and the letters of Procopius of Gaza

Among the few untranslated letters of St Jerome, Epistle 150 is a very short item which is completely spurious.  This is because it is from Procopius of Gaza, the late 5th-early 6th century sophist.  Note that this is not the more famous, and slightly later, historian Procopius of Caesarea, who chronicled the wars of Justinian.  The letter is indeed written to a “Hieronymus”, but it is to another Jerome, one who lives in Egypt.

It seems that there is no translation of the letters of Procopius in English, nor French.  But a complete and rather charming translation exists in Italian, translated beautifully by Federica Ciccolella, and edited by Eugenio Amato, Rose di Gaza: Gli scritti retorico-sofistici e le Epistole di Procopio di Gaza, Edizionei dell’Orso (2010).  I was very fortunate to obtain access to a copy.

It turns out that Jerome, Letter 150, is letter 81 of the collected letters of Procopius of Gaza. The simplest way to discover this was to search for letters addressed to Jerome, and run them through DeepSeek AI translation.  I’ve not checked the results, but they’re probably good enough for casual use, and I thought that I would share a few with you, and a few excerpts from the wonderful footnotes.

9.  To Jerome.

I thought my sister’s wedding was a secret, not that it was known to all who live near my house, let alone to you—I believed you were still by the Nile. But it seems nothing related to luxury escapes you; indeed, as soon as an event occurs, the scent of celebration reaches you from afar. Perhaps you can outdo the Homeric Zeus in your love for libations and the fat that curls in spirals of smoke.

This is what the Nile and the fortunate men who live along that river have instilled in you, and now, residing in Elusa, your senses have grown even sharper whenever smoke rises from the earth. As for your slave, I was almost moved to treat him poorly for not having you write the letter in full. But since he brought gifts from you, the sight of them changed my mind and, somehow, dissolved my anger. I will respond to these matters briefly: for either a little daughter has been born to you, or one is about to be born.

I learn from the excellent notes that Elusa was a city in the northern Negev, about 30 miles from Gaza, and the most important city in the region.  Despite the aridity of the area, the city was prosperous thanks to the caravan traffic.  Christianity arrived around 400 and the desert setting became the home of monks and hermits.  Drought and shifting sands were a constant threat to urban life, and the city was abandoned in the 8th century.  Procopius emphasises how poor it was compared to wealthy Alexandria, where many citizens of Elusa migrated: the city was a “hell” (ep. 87) where the water tasted salty, bread was made of barley (ep. 2, 91) and wind and sand interfered with the cultivation of vines (ep. 81).

81.  To Jerome.

Egypt and luxury again—we are so poor compared to you, with no thought for those left far behind. But that is nothing—by all means, let it be so, if only you may laugh while seeing the Nile flow like gold! And even if you raise your eyebrow still higher, we will certainly bear being scorned. For a day will come when you will see Elusa once more and weep for the sand borne on the wind, which strips the vines down to their roots. There dwell only a few desert and brackish nymphs, while Zeus the Rain‑giver is nowhere to be found. Then it will be my turn to laugh and write a comedy about fate, while you will deem me happy—the one you now despise. But so long as the Nile allows you such airs, at least write, and go ahead and call us insignificant creatures who walk the earth. Thus we will be happy if you write, and at the same time we will comfort ourselves for your arrogance with hope in the future.

Vines were grown in Elusa, all the same, and the archaeology includes a huge wine-press.  Of course in Elusa men had to walk, rather than ride on boats on the Nile.

86.  To Jerome

It should have been you, my friend—you who have gone away from us—to begin the correspondence and to inform us, who miss you greatly, whether Poseidon has been favorable to you and made the sea smooth for your ship, whether your situation in the city of Alexander is favorable, whether you have happily sailed up the abundant Nile, whether your school is thriving, and consequently, whether you have heaps of money and your house is overflowing with Egyptian gifts. You ought to have written these things and kept your promises—promises that included frequent letters, but not the forgetting of friends. Yet you do not even care who writes to you, refusing to reply to letters! Indeed, this is already the second one I have sent you, and if you continue to keep silent, we will soon add a third, until at least some shame over your behaviour seizes you and we manage to hear your voice.

Procopius complains that Jerome hasn’t written after his arrival in Alexandria – is this perhaps an earlier letter, chronologically?  The comments about how the riches of Egypt and how Jerome must be making a fortune have the feel of a standing joke between the two friends.

91. To Jerome.

What a grave accusation you have brought against us—we, the arrogant, the overly sophistical, those sick with pride behind a modest appearance! I could not even begin to count how many arguments you have piled up against us, as though you have long been waiting for the moment to unleash your tongue upon us. And so, without even giving a just cause, you bring forth what you had long kept hidden. So tell me: what is so terrible if, in writing to you, I began the letter with “Procopius greets Jerome”? I am certain you yourself would agree that this follows ancient usage. “But there is no need,” you say, “to depart from the custom that now prevails.” Well then, go ahead and accuse even one who wishes to restore the pomposity that now reigns to its ancient dignity, and to return to the muse of Terpander the music that has sunk into meaningless songs and popular trifles!

But why, by Zeus, protector of friendship, would you yourself appear solemn if you uttered some Attic phrase and won approval for conforming to the ancient rules, when you can fill yourself with common words and carry them to the public assembly? Or why, when you sit in your chair before the young, do you think it right to present them with some mighty phrase of the famous Aristides in order to gain approval by speaking like him? Did not Polemon cleanse ancient rhetoric of Asian charlatanry? If fate had granted you to be born back then, I believe you would perhaps even bring an accusation against him for neglecting custom and daring to be presumptuous by returning to the ancient art.

If only the Spartan table were in fashion again and our diet were like that of the ancient Persians: barley bread, water, and cress! Even now one could see such foods prevailing in your Elusa—not from an excess of temperance, but because those are the few provisions that land laboriously supplies to its inhabitants. And yet, now that you have learned Egyptian luxury, you have cast off your ancestral customs: you, who prescribe maintaining traditions even beyond what is fitting!

Moreover, calling me arrogant for placing your name after mine seems typical of someone unaware that what comes first in order does not at all hold the first place in value, or who pretends not to know the saying of Demosthenes that children are fond of reciting: that action, compared to speaking and voting, though last in order, is first and strongest in effect. But if you simply condemn this as presumption, it is time to include in the vice of insolence, along with me, all those who in ancient times used such forms of address—among whom, leaving others aside, I number Socrates and Plato, who raised philosophy to the heavens.

But as for arrogance, stop it from now on, and do not turn the proverb’s knife against yourself. Or is it not true that your own tales have long been known: that no sooner had you disembarked than the sons of the Egyptians accompanied you in procession with a barbarous shout, and there was a celebration no less solemn than when, in former times, a fortunate generation gave them Apis; and that, having become puffed up in mind for these reasons, you not only called me—living in a small city—a man of little worth, but also neglected your homeland, your wife, and even your own son? And perhaps you considered me, who practice philosophy, of no value because I did not receive abundant applause from a confused roar—oh Zeus!—and a barbarous tongue? What is worse, you called yourself a happy man only because they made your house overflow with food and meat. See how puffed up you have become over trifles, you who now accuse me of arrogance!

And I say this—by the gods!—not because I wish to take revenge for your words (for I do not think that would accord with my philosophy), but because, if possible, I want to make your tongue more moderate. But be careful not to refrain from writing us such things, frightened by the power of my words! For, in the name of your Nile and the Graces who dwell near you, I presented your letter as a public rhetorical exhibition, and it was recited to everyone in the center of Gaza. And I was ashamed to be called arrogant in your letter, and the public laughed at me, while you seemed to succeed with your arguments.

And our final quote.

124. To Jerome.

How proudly you parade along the Nile and attack us, dragging Egypt into it, as though you had reached the point of forgetting our dear Elusa! So not only are your letters sophistical, but I seemed even to see the arrogance of Gorgias in them. For you said that the Nile rains from the earth — if I have not missed some word — and makes navigable what was once passable on foot.(585) But what does that have to do with you, who live in the city of Hermes,(586) a place Zeus the Rain‑giver does not even glance at while the Nile, flowing past it, hastens elsewhere? And then why do you lie about harvesting crops? Unless you call “crops” the snakes and scorpions that swarm there. Reportedly, once, stung by one of them, they say you cried out, “Ah, ah!” Then, catching sight meanwhile of a lavish table, you threw yourself wholeheartedly toward it, greeting the scorpion — perhaps after uttering this comic line: “Even in death may I never be without you!”(588) This is what you should have written, not boasting with the goods of others! Yet you also accuse me of silence when it is you who tells us nothing at all. Of course, you could have found someone more talkative, and then you would not cite to us Cotocides(589), who mocked the sophists for being like flutes. Farewell, with your son and your wife. And do not loom sternly over your son Alexander, imposing too much effort on one so young.

585.  A reference to a widely held theory in antiquity that the Nile’s floods were caused by the surge of a river—a sort of second Nile that, on certain days of the year, emerged onto the surface from subterranean caves.
586.  Hermopolis Magna, modern Al-Ashmounein, a dry location which has preserved many papyri.
588.  Euripedes, Alcestis 367-8, reused in Aristophanes Acharnians 893-4.
598. Aeschines is called “Cotocides” by Demosthenes (13, 29). The allusion could concern Aeschin., 3,229, or some passage of a lost oration.

Obviously this is DeepSeek, and I haven’t gone through it line by line.  But it’s all very readable, and I truly wish these letters existed in English, with footnotes at the bottom of the page.  This is the sort of thing that Penguin did so well under Betty Radice with Pliny’s Letters.  Could someone do this again for Procopius?  I see that Federica Ciccolella seems to be at Texas A&M University, so must have good English.  Perhaps she could supervise a graduate student to do them for the ACW or FOC series?

The “Life” of St Botolph by Folcard, with epitomes and breviary readings, English and Latin – now online (BHL 1428, BHL 1429, BHL 1430, BHL 1431))

About 1070 AD, the abbot of Thorney Abbey in Cambridgeshire, a chap named Folcard of St Bertin, wrote an account of the life of St Botolph, one of the saints whose relics were venerated at the abbey.  St Botolph was a popular saint in England and also in Scandinavia.  There are still about 40 churches dedicated to St Botolph in England.  Botolph himself was an Anglo-Saxon, who introduced the Benedictine rule to England, and founded a monastery at Iken on the Suffolk coast.

No English translation of this “Life” has ever been published.  The printed text in the Acta Sanctorum is defective.  So for some months I have been creating a critical Latin text and a translation of it.  I’ve also included an abbreviated life that circulated, two other texts that Folcard wrote along with the Life about the saints of Thorney Abbey, and a  bunch of readings from breviaries – medieval service books – which included a commemoration of St Botolph.

It’s pretty much done, and so I am going to release it today.

I’ve also uploaded these to Archive.org, here.

As usual, the files are public domain.  Do whatever you like with them, personal, educational or commercial.

There is one loose end to the project: I have not been able to collate the York manuscript of the abbreviated life.  If this appears, I will upload a revised version.

How many letters of St Jerome remain untranslated into English?

In my last post, I gave a few notes on the letters of St. Jerome, which number 154 in the Hilberg edition in the Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum Latinorum series, vols.54, 55 and 56.  It seems that complete translations exist into French and Spanish.  But in English, as we all know, many letters remain untranslated.

Well, it seems that this is not true.  A total of SEVEN letters remain untranslated.  Two of these (93 and 94) are short notes by other people in response to a synodical letter of Theophilus of Alexandria, translated into Latin by Jerome and included in his letters.  The others are letters 150-154.  150 is completely bogus, a letter of Procopius of Gaza, who lived a century later, to some other Hieronymus.  Hilberg didn’t bother to print this, although Migne did.  Letters 149-154 are tiny, and occupy together the last 10 pages of Hilberg.

To discover this, I compiled a list of the letters and their translations, in a spreadsheet.  It’s here:

Remarkable, really.  I had no idea that we were so close.  I will translate the rest myself!

Update (15 Dec 2025): I’ve added columns for Paul Carroll and Michael Graves. With thanks for info to Twitter poster @discerninganew.

Update (22 Dec 2025): I’ve added to the spreadsheet the translation of letter 148 by B.R. Rees.  With thanks to Rafael Rodrigues for raising the question.

Update (06 Jan 2026): I have now created a file with the Latin text and English translation of the remaining letters.  Here they are:

They can also be downloaded from Archive.org here.

As always these are public domain.  Do whatever you like with them, personal, educational or commercial.

I have also updated the spreadsheet.  I believe that we now have all the letters of Jerome in English.  The only uncertainty is that I have not checked myself that 149 does exist in *English* in the volume given, but am relying on a reference.  This I will investigate.

The letters of St. Jerome

The Letters of St. Jerome (CPL 620), who died in 420 AD, are one of the great collections of ancient letters.  Inquiring, it seems that Quasten’s  Patrology vol. 4 (ed. Angelo di Berardino) still gives far better information than anything Google has to offer. The collection contains 154 letters, which includes letters addressed to St Jerome by other people.  It also includes translations of Greek documents made by Jerome as part of the Origenist disputes.  Letters 148-150 are apocryphal.

The standard critical edition was made by the Austrian Isidore Hilberg for the CSEL series (vols. 54, 55 and 56) in 3 volumes between 1910-1918, although he did not live to see it published.  A fourth volume of indexes has appeared recently.  The edition has some odd choices of spellings, some rejected by Jerome himself!  It also does not use all of the oldest manuscripts.

No complete English translation exists.  A limited number of important letters were translated by W. H. Freemantle in the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers series.  The first22 letters appear in the ACW series vol. 33, from 1963, but it looks as if the translators went no further.

But a complete translation does exist in French, made by Jérôme Labourt, “Jérôme: Correspondance”, in 8 volumes Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1949-63).  This includes a critical text, but mainly still based on Hilberg.  Labourt died before completing his work; a review of tome 7 noted the lack of notes. There are also extensive – complete? – translations in multiple volumes in Italian.

Update: See the next post here for a spreadsheet of all letters of Jerome for which an English translation exists.

From my diary

The last day was mostly lost in trying to sort out two problems with the blog software.  First, when posting a link to a post to Twitter, no image appeared.  Secondly, if I added a comment to a post, I – the author – got no email notification.

Yesterday I got fed up and delved into the WordPress code.  It’s PHP, after all, which is a language that I have used before.  A bit of debugging using PHP error_log() calls revealed that… if an author comments on his own post, by default WordPress doesn’t notify him.  Which is why I never saw any notifications.  Nor does WordPress make this a setting in the dashboard.  The change makes debugging a new installation that little bit harder.  The answer is to comment from another browser – one you are not logged into.  But of course nobody would  know that by default.

Anyway the code makes clear what the answer is: to write a little single-file plugin that overrides a WordPress function and returns “true”.  This I have done, and it works just fine.  Here it is:

If you activate the plugin, it overrides the bit of code (in wp-includes/pluggable.php) that checks whether author comments should trigger a notification email.  If you deactivate it, it removes that.

I’d always wondered about how to write my own plugin.  Fortunately it’s simple.

Now to see whether the Twitter stuff works or not.

The Hereford Breviary

A number of pre-reformation church service books were printed, and this naturally included  breviaries, some of which contained readings from the Life of St Botolph.  I don’t know if there is a list somewhere of what exists and what is in each, beyond the excellent Usuarium website.

In 1505 a breviary for Hereford Abbey was printed in Rouen (Rotomagus) by a certain Inghelbert Haghe.  I learn from an 1893 book1 that:

Of this book only three copies are known. One, textually perfect, and containing both parts, is in Worcester Cathedral Library. The Bodleian has a Pars Estivalis, slightly imperfect, and another copy is in private hands.

A wretched microfilm of the Bodleian copy of the first part is in Early English Books Online (EEBO).  This database is only accessible to research libraries who subscribe, which is a bit sad.  But as I discovered today, it is actually quite difficult to find this book even in EEBO, thanks to the abbreviated title.  The searcher is advised to look for “Breuiariu secundu vsum herford”!  The url is here.

Breuiariu[m] secundu[m] vsum herford
Alternate title: Breviary. Hereford
Bibliographic name/number: STC (2nd ed.) / 15793.
Anonymous; Catholic Church.  EEBO Bodleian Library records – unstructured. [526] p. London: Emporio [P. Olivier and J. Mauditier] impensis et cura Ingheiberti haghe [in London, at the expenses of Margaret, Countess of Richmond] ,, 1505.

The copy comes complete with copyright notice, or rather, admission of guilt.

The rest of the PDF is no better, and often far worse.  Is it better than nothing?  Not really.  If anybody from ProQuest is reading this, it would be good to improve things here.

The Hereford Breviary was edited under that title in three volumes for the Henry Bradshaw Society by W.H.Frere, in 1904.  Here are the volumes at Archive.org:

But, incredibly, it is not printed in full!  p.vii:

It has already been stated that the text is not given in full; various reasons led to this course: the full text seemed unnecessary because so much of it is common to other Uses ; and moreover a student with one Breviary before him, wishing to trace out its differences from another, is hindered rather than helped by having the second one in full; he would rather have its differences pointed out than its whole text.

The man who wrote those works must have anticipated the infuriated reaction of researchers.  And indeed the lections of the saints’ offices are not included.  The only information is from vol. 2, p.194, where we learn that there are three readings.

While an 1893 book is not necessarily the last word on bibliography, it seems that the only way to access the full text is to be very nice to the Dean and Chapter of Worcester Cathedral.  A fine body of men, no doubt!  But I think that, just between you and I, this breviary may get omitted from my collection of Botolph materials.

  1. E. Gordon Duff, Early Printed Books. London, 1893. Online here.[↩]

From my diary

The aftermath of the hack has taken a solid week to clean up.  But it is done.  Cross fingers, it won’t happen again, or not soon.  It’s not as if my little blog attracts enough traffic to be worth their while.  At least next time I will be better prepared.

This afternoon I have started looking at John Toy, English saints in the Medieval Liturgies of the Scandinavian churches, 2009, which has a section on St Botolph material.  He lists some 42 breviaries that contain readings from the Life of St Botolph.  Ouch.  I’ve also found that there is stuff in the York and Hereford breviaries, and no doubt others.

Today I located the Lund Breviary online, in Uppsala university, shelfmark C447, and downloaded it.  It is yet another scruffily written, hard to make out manuscript. There’s a long section of Botolph material, none of which I can read with ease.

I think it may be necessary to rule the breviaries “out of scope.”  There’s just too much material.  Possibly it needs a separate project to look at those, although really it’s for someone far more knowledgeable than myself to undertake.  The original idea was just to create an English translation of the medieval Life of St Botolph, remember.

But after a hard week, I think I shall bunk off and play a computer game or something!  Have a good weekend, everyone.

On the Fourth Day

Behind the blog surface, the posts are stored in a database.  The pharm spam hack inserted stuff into that database, and I have spent two days in cleaning it.  This I did by exporting the database to a .sql file using the PhpMyAdmin interface; importing it into a local WordPress instance running on my PC; importing the last sound backup into another local WordPress instance; exporting the sound wp-posts table from that, renaming it, importing it into the same database as the  corrupt one, and doing lots of SQL queries to locate the differences.  It has been time-consuming, but not different in kind to the sort of stuff that I used to do for  money, when I was working for insurance companies and fixing live problems in their databases.  I’ve found it rather relaxing.  You have to get into the right frame of mind to do it, to see the problem – and how to fix it – in terms of an SQL query.  But this I did professionally for 30 years, so it was not troublesome.  The main thing to remember is not to panic.

After all that, I hope that the annoying pharma links are gone, and that I haven’t broken anything!

I’ve brought up a new instance of WordPress on the server.  I’ve also changed the theme, although I may change it again.

A rather impressive security plugin located three files on the disk which the hacker had left there.  One of these was so poisonous that when I downloaded it to my PC in order to inspect it, my local antivirus promptly whipped it away into quarantine.  I will do more security work on the blog tomorrow.

In the meantime, there has been a little progress on St. Botolph, which I am very keen to finish.  A kind gentleman has sent me the modern text of the Linkoping breviary text.  Another commented and transcribed the manuscript that I could not read.  Finally the rather comprehensive book by John Toy arrived with massive information on Scandinavian breviaries.  I’ve not had time to look at any of these yet, but these have been a light in the darkness.

I’ve discovered that a breviary from Hereford probably also contains a text, and that I might be able to access this through Early English Books Online (EEBO).  I have no access to EEBO, but a nearby library probably does, and probably will allow me to use it.  Maybe next week!

On the Second Day…

Today has been spent researching how to rescue my content from the spam attack that is poisoning a lot of the older articles with unwanted links.

It’s becoming clear that WordPress’ built in export and import are barely useful; and are NOT used by professionals who run websites based around it.  What they do is use professional (and very expensive) tools to migrate the data from a “staging” copy of WordPress, where everything is developed and written, across to the “live” site.  When they do work with the content, they work directly with the database behind WordPress.  They export and import whole databases, when they’re not using migration tools.

For them, this means that an attack on the “live” site is meaningless, a minor interruption.  They just erase it and push a new copy across from their local site to the server.

This is excellent practice, and commonplace in IT in general.

So the way forward is to do all my content creation on a WordPress Instance running on my PC, and then migrate it to live, if I can.  Rather a come-down from entering my posts online directly, but it would work.

But that doesn’t help me with retrieving my data.  So I have been burrowing into the database underneath.  The very simple, very obvious database, if you are a retired professional database developer, as I am.

Today I have been setting up LocalWP on my PC.  This has gone reasonably well except that I have to pause my antivirus when creating a new WordPress instance.  And then remember to reenable it.  This is because it locks the hosts file, which LocalWP edits really rather often.  Daft design, really.  I’ve also been working with the command-line interface, WP-CLI, locally.  This also has a bug, where the DB_HOST variable in wp-config.php does not include the port number.  Everything works, other than WP-CLI doing database stuff.  A nuisance.

So I created an empty WordPress locally, and then tried to import the last valid backup.  The import failed.  It’s simply not designed to take a 70mb file.  That’s really wretched.  Come on WordPress, this is basic functionality!  I then ran the import using WP-CLI where – to my astonishment – it took a couple of hours to load 7,400 blog posts.  I learned from this that the professionals simply don’t use the WordPress Export/Import in any way.

But it did load.  Which gives me a WordPress instance with a clean copy of all the corrupted posts.

In theory, one should be able to connect to the live system database, and run a cross database update to restore the correct content fields.  I have some doubts that little old MySQL databases can handle that, unlike the Oracle monsters that I knew!  I imagine it would all time out.

But possibly I could simply start my own MySQL database, independently of WordPress; then import into it the clean database file that I have created, import it as a whole; then rename all the tables imported from WP_xyz to something else – maybe VALID_xyz.  Then I could import an export of the “live” system into the same database, somehow; and then do the update from one to the other locally?  UPDATE WP-POSTS from VALID_POSTS or something – I don’t know what the syntax would be as yet.  Then drop the VALID tables, export the whole database, now fixed; and create a new instance on the server using the new cleaned up database.  Or something like that.

Um yes.  I’m sure most of you swallowed.  I’m an old database programmer. I think in these terms when obliged to.

It is pathetic and ridiculous that such maneouvres should be necessary.  Not one blogger in ten thousand would think in such terms.  Blogging is for convenience.  How is all this “convenient”?  Tools that do not work, software that is insecure, timeouts all over the place?

Still, it’s clearly possible.  It will just take a ridiculous amount of time.

First attempts at recovery

It’s been an arduous afternoon, trying to work out how to recover from the hack last year that has poisoned hundreds of posts on this site.  The site currently includes 4,741 posts containing 3,096,019 words.  That’s a lot to go through manually.  And since I don’t know how the hack was done, or whether it is still active, or a backdoor is present, then it might be futile.

I’ve done a few grep searches on the most recent backup file.  A search for “cialis” alone gave over 250 results.  Of course I have no idea of all the possible spam terms.

But I have been a good boy, and made regular backups.  I do have a backup of the site, taken a month earlier.  In theory I should just be able to create a new WordPress installation, and restore that, and then handle the last year bit by bit.

So I created a new, clean WordPress installation.  Unfortunately… the backup times out.  It’s 70mb, which is too long for some timeout somewhere.  Why doesn’t it batch the thing?

No worries, there’s a command-line interface to wordpress, WP-CLI.  That runs… and gets killed by something or other, possibly the site operators, more likely a robot for running out of memory.

I’m leaving the damaged site up at the moment.  I will ponder.

PS:  It just occurred to me… maybe I should run WordPress on my PC, do the import there, and then export the contents in pieces, and load these?  What a faff.