{"id":11733,"date":"2013-10-04T23:56:42","date_gmt":"2013-10-04T22:56:42","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/?p=11733"},"modified":"2013-10-04T23:56:42","modified_gmt":"2013-10-04T22:56:42","slug":"ehrman-on-the-long-recension-of-ignatius","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2013\/10\/04\/ehrman-on-the-long-recension-of-ignatius\/","title":{"rendered":"Ehrman on the long recension of Ignatius"},"content":{"rendered":"<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Some busy days have prevented me getting to grips with Ehrman&#8217;s <em>Forgery and counterforgery<\/em>.\u00a0 My query about the Apollinarians earlier today led me back to it, as a Google link brought me to the Google Books version, where I found material on the long recension of the letters of Ignatius of Antioch.\u00a0 I thought that I would review this section, therefore.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Pages 460-480 are headed &#8220;the pseudo-Ignatian letters&#8221;.\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0Let&#8217;s have\u00a0a quick refresher on the background.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">In the Greek manuscript tradition we find numerous manuscripts of a collection of 13 letters attributed to Ignatius of Antioch, the apostolic father.\u00a0 This is known as the long recension; for 7 of these letters have reached us, but only just, in a handful of manuscripts in a shorter version, which we will refer to as the short version.\u00a0 The differences between the two seem to relate to late 4th century theological arguments, with an Apollinarian or Arian tinge.\u00a0 Finally there is a Syriac epitome of 3 of the letters, and I have seen a reference in Aphram Barsoum to Syriac texts of other letters.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">E. begins by stating more or less what\u00a0I have told you, and then discusses the discovery in the 17th c. by Archbishop Ussher that the long version had been tampered with, and the recovery of the short version.\u00a0 He then moves on to discuss the author, summarising the scholarship of Lightfoot and others, and including the recent (1975) work of D. Hagedorn suggesting that the interpolator is the same as the author of a commentary on Job attributed to Origen.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_1_11733\" id=\"awef_ident_1_11733\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"E. does not give the full bibliographic reference: it is Dieter Hagedorn, Der Hiobkommentar des Arianers Julian, Patristische Texte und Studien, 14, Berlin: deGruyter, 1975.\">1<\/a><\/sup><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">E. usefully describes the argument that the commentary author may be an otherwise unknown Julian of Antioch, so named in 1 manuscript of a catena which sometimes ascribes the work to &#8220;Julian&#8221; &#8212; the abbreviated designations in catenae are a nuisance! &#8212; and whose name\u00a0is, we are told, present in the prologue.\u00a0 E. tells us that Hagedorn thought that the two works are by the same author, as well as the <em>Apostolic Constitutions,<\/em> a church order of the same period,\u00a0introducing itself as from the apostles.\u00a0 Usefully he tells us why the commentary and the <em>AC<\/em> should be associated: &#8220;&#8230;35 points of contact &#8230; precisely the same topics, using precisely the same somewhat unusual expressions&#8221; and then that verbatim similarities of wording show that the author of the long recension and the commentary must be the same.\u00a0 The argument is, on the face of it, a reasonable one; although arguments based on similarities are notoriously subjective, and can easily give false positives.\u00a0 The Arian nature of the <em>Commentary<\/em> is also explained &#8212; the author rejects both <em>homoousios <\/em>and <em>homoiousios<\/em>, which marks him plainly as an Arian.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">However E. then goes on to address objections to the identification without actually making clear what those objections are.\u00a0 The main objection is that the long recension is not markedly Arian, while the <em>Commentary<\/em> makes its loyalties quite clear.\u00a0 This E. evades by appealing to the idea that the author might have developed his views.\u00a0 So he might; but the reader deserves to have the objection stated plainly.\u00a0 To his credit E. makes clear that there is anti-Arian seeming material in the long recension.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">The next section is entitled &#8220;Purpose of the forgeries&#8221;.\u00a0 It is hard to say why somebody composed the long recension, for the obvious reason that we know nothing for certain about the author (aside from the proposals of Hagedorn), and certainly not what his motivations were.\u00a0E. proceeds to discuss this by suggesting that much of the material\u00a0is written as if from\u00a0a 2nd century outlook, and attack various heresies of the period, as listed in the stock anti-heretical treatises of the 4th century.\u00a0 All this material is useful, and\u00a0E.&#8217;s acknowledgement of Lightfoot is generous.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">But at\u00a0this point E.&#8217;s over-emphasis on &#8220;forgery! forgery!&#8221; causes\u00a0the reader\u00a0confusion.\u00a0\u00a0E. tells us that the author must have wanted to put forward his own theological position.\u00a0 This is probable enough, to be sure;\u00a0but it tells us little, for the same is true of most authors, and we have already seen that we don&#8217;t know for sure what the author&#8217;s theology was, unless we accept Hagedorn&#8217;s theory.\u00a0 Worse, it is speculation.\u00a0 We don&#8217;t <em>know<\/em> what\u00a0the author\u00a0wanted: we can only infer.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">Next he tells us that the author is:<\/p>\n<blockquote>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">&#8230; clearly engaged, consciously, in the act of forgery&#8230;<\/p>\n<\/blockquote>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">But surely we do not know this?\u00a0 It is likely enough, again; but we actually know nothing about the origins of the long recension, nothing about its author, and treating theory as fact is for politicians, not scholars.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">E. however believes that\u00a0we know the author intended forgery\u00a0because of the author&#8217;s &#8220;attempts at verisimilitude&#8221; and because some of his alterations to the genuine text are &#8220;highly significant&#8221;.\u00a0 The logic is not easy to follow here.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">The\u00a0first point will make little sense to us unless we realise that E. is trying throughout his book to argue that small personal details in letters, far from being indications of authenticity, are in fact indications of forgery &#8212; he is, inevitably, thinking primarily of reasons to debunk the N.T. here.\u00a0 Such broadbrush arguments are not impressive: if I write a letter, or a blog post, what I put in it depends on who I write to and what I have to say, and how I feel.\u00a0 It would be unwise for E. to assign posts on this blog as &#8220;authentic&#8221; or &#8220;interpolated&#8221;, based on such a criterion.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">The second point is left unclear; but E. then devotes a couple of pages to &#8220;important features&#8221; of the long recension, which is probably intended as explanation.\u00a0 Unfortunately it is not easy to follow the argument, nor the connection to what precedes and follows it.\u00a0\u00a0Lack of focus\u00a0is a failing of this book throughout.\u00a0 It makes it very hard to read a work critically, when the\u00a0subject\u00a0drifts off into points whose connection with the topic is tenuous.\u00a0 Here E. has been poorly served by his publisher, who should most certainly have edited it more tightly.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">He then moves onto some work of his own, looking for theological battle-cries in the text of the long recension (including changes to Ignatius&#8217; own wording) and finding many phrases which sound a bit heretical, in one way or another, notably with a subordinationist flavour.\u00a0 These ought to be tabulated, not left in the body of the text.\u00a0 But this leads the reader nowhere; the text again loses focus and drifts off into a very vague discussion of whether the author might or might not be an Arian, and might be addressing somebody unknown rather like Marcellus of Ancyra.\u00a0 This takes up most of the remainder of the section, and might perhaps be useful to someone interested in the long recension.\u00a0 As E. rightly remarks, a thorough study would be nice to have.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">One defect in this last section of the text is\u00a0that E., on p.476, having already presented his data on fingerprint phrases\u00a0on p.470-4,\u00a0then starts to list further pieces of data.\u00a0\u00a0This is very naughty.\u00a0 Any critical\u00a0reader will\u00a0demand all of the data first; and then the theory later.\u00a0 For to mingle the two makes it hard for the reader to evaluate the argument.\u00a0 Indeed doing so\u00a0is a trick of polemicists to shut down disagreement; and again the publisher should have caught this.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: justify;\">The discussion of the long recension is a bit waffly.\u00a0 The bits that are good are mainly by others, and the bits that are original are not that well structured.\u00a0 But on the whole it&#8217;s a useful summary.<\/p>\n\t\t\t<style>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\tol.footnotes.awepost_11733>li {list-style-type:decimal;}\n\t\t\t\tol.footnotes.awepost_11733>li>span.symbol {display: none;}\n\t\t\tol.footnotes { color:#666666; }\r\nol.footnotes li { font-size:80%; }\t\t\t<\/style>\n\t\t\t<ol start=\"1\" class=\"footnotes awepost_11733\">\n\t<li id=\"footnote_1_11733\" class=\"footnote\">E. does not give the full bibliographic reference: it is Dieter Hagedorn, <em>Der Hiobkommentar des Arianers Julian<\/em>, Patristische Texte und Studien, 14, Berlin: deGruyter, 1975.<span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2013\/10\/04\/ehrman-on-the-long-recension-of-ignatius\/#awef_ident_1_11733\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><\/ol>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Some busy days have prevented me getting to grips with Ehrman&#8217;s Forgery and counterforgery.\u00a0 My query about the Apollinarians earlier today led me back to it, as<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"advanced_seo_description":"","jetpack_seo_html_title":"","jetpack_seo_noindex":false,"jetpack_seo_schema_type":"","_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"_awef_post_faq_schema":[],"_jetpack_hide_featured_image":false,"_jetpack_featured_image_duplicate_dismissed":0,"_jetpack_feature_clip_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[19],"tags":[273,714,881],"class_list":["post-11733","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-from-my-diary-announcements","tag-bart-ehrman","tag-forgery-and-counterforgery","tag-ignatius"],"jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/11733","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=11733"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/11733\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=11733"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=11733"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=11733"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}