{"id":19222,"date":"2019-05-29T14:30:50","date_gmt":"2019-05-29T13:30:50","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/?p=19222"},"modified":"2019-05-29T14:30:50","modified_gmt":"2019-05-29T13:30:50","slug":"theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/","title":{"rendered":"Theophanes III of Nicaea and the light of God as the fire of hell for those who reject Him"},"content":{"rendered":"<p align=\"justify\">The Wikipedia article on the \u201cLight of Tabor\u201d &#8211; the divine light seen by the disciples on Mount Tabor \u2013 mentions that \u201cTheophanes of Nicaea\u201d believed that \u201cthe divine light will be perceived as the punishing fire of hell\u201d.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_1_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_1_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"https:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Tabor_Light. The reference given is &ldquo;Ioann\u0113s Polem\u0113s, Theophanes of Nicaea: His Life and Works, vol. 20 (Verlag der &Ouml;sterreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1996), p. 99&rdquo;.\">1<\/a><\/sup> This is indeed true, although Theophanes is actually merely following Gregory Nazianzen here.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_2_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_2_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"Polemis p.99: &ldquo;The view that the light of God&rsquo;s glory is identical with the fire of hell is quite common among the Greek Fathers and can be traced back to Gregory of Nazianzos, who affirms in a passage quoted by Theophanes without acknowledgment that the punishment of sinners will be \u1f61&sigmaf; &pi;\u1fe6&rho; \u1f30&delta;&epsilon;\u1fd6&nu;, \u1f45&nu; \u1f61&sigmaf; &phi;\u1ff6&sigmaf; &omicron;\u1f50&kappa; \u1f10&gamma;&nu;\u1f7d&rho;&iota;&sigma;&alpha;&nu;&rdquo; (&ldquo;seeing Him to be fire whom he did not recognise as light&rdquo;), and n. 109: &ldquo;Gregory of Nazianzus In laudem Athanasii, PG 35, 1084D,&rdquo; i.e. the funeral oration for Athanasius, oratio XXI, chapter 2. English translation http:\/\/www.tertullian.org\/fathers2\/NPNF2-07\/Npnf2-07-40.htm#P4015_1195110\">2<\/a><\/sup><\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">But who is this Theophanes of Nicaea? There is no Wikipedia article on him; and even the <em>Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium<\/em> does not consider him worth a mention. He is sometimes confused with his predecessor bishop at Nicaea, Theophanes the Confessor, also known as Theophanes Graptos (d. 845).\u00a0 I thought that it would be useful to collect what I could on this minor figure as an orientation guide in case others have to work in this area.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">In the late 14<sup>th<\/sup> century the works of Thomas Aquinas began to be known in the remains of the Byzantine empire. Translations were made by Demetrius Cydones. Naturally this instantly provoked one of those lengthy pseudo-theological quarrels so beloved of the decaying state, which are associated with the name of St Gregory Palamas and are known to us as the Hesychast controversy. A circle of intellectuals formed around the former emperor John VI Cantacuzene, who had resigned in 1354 and become a monk under the name of Joasaph. One of these young men was Theophanes, a very minor late Byzantine writer.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">We know very little about Theophanes. We don\u2019t even know the name that he was born with \u2013 Theophanes is his name in religion. We don\u2019t know when he was born, where, or what family he came from. He was a disciple of the Patriarch Philotheus Kokkinus of Constantinople (1354-5, and again 1364-7), as appears in the compliments made in his <em>First Oration on the Light of Tabor<\/em>. Theophanes appears for the first time in 1366 in a legal act. This he signed as Theophanes, Metropolitan of Nicaea. But Nicaea had been occupied by the Turks since 1331, so the appointment was merely an honour.\u00a0 He was probably selected as bishop by his master after 1364. He was unable to visit Nicaea\u00a0as he tells us in the third of his <em>Three Letters to Nicaea<\/em>. Instead he resided in Constantinople and busied himself with church business.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">One part of this business was the task of responding to a letter from the Latin \u201cpatriarch of Constantinople\u201d, Paul, bishop of Smyrna. Pope Innocent VI had asked Paul to write to John\/Joasaph for information about the hesychast controversy. The ex-emperor prudently deputed the task, and Theophanes wrote a <em>Letter to Paul<\/em> on the subject.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">Philotheus placed Theophanes in charge of the investigation into the opinions of Prochorus Cydones about Hesychasm, and therefore many of his works are concerned with this. But he relinquished the role to concentrate on the reunion with the church of Serbia.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_3_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_3_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"See review of Polemis at https:\/\/www.persee.fr\/doc\/rebyz_0766-5598_1997_num_55_1_1946_t1_0348_0000_3\">3<\/a><\/sup><\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">Between 1367 and 1368 Theophanes acted as ambassador for Philotheus to John Ugljesa, the despot of Serbia, to negotiate the reunion of the Serbian church with Constantinople. In consequence his signature is absent from the Tomos of 1368, in which Prochorus Cydones was condemned.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">Theophanes was the first Byzantine theologian to use the works of Aquinas, even prior to Scholarios. These he knew through the translations into Greek by Demetrius Cydones.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">No further mention of Theophanes is known after June 1380, and in March 1381 a new bishop, Alexios of Varna, is consecrated to Nicaea.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">The majority of the works of Theophanes remain unpublished and accessible only in manuscript. The following works have been printed:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>Three pastoral letters<\/li>\n<li><em>Oratio Eucharistica<\/em>.\u00a0 The eucharistic prayer<\/li>\n<li><em>Sermo in Sanctissimam Deiparam<\/em><em>.\u00a0 <\/em>Oration on the most holy Mother of God (theotokos)<\/li>\n<li><em>De lumine uiso in monte Thabor<\/em>. \u00a0Five orations on the Light of Tabor.<\/li>\n<li><em>De aeternitate mundi<\/em>.\u00a0 A treatise on the eternity of the world<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Unedited works include:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li><em>Contra Latinos<\/em>.\u00a0 Four orations against the Latins, rejecting the filioque.<\/li>\n<li><em>Contra Judaeos<\/em>.\u00a0 Eight orations and twenty-five chapters against the Jews.<\/li>\n<li><em>Epistola ad Paulum<\/em>.\u00a0 Letter to the legate Paul<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>A further work is not known to exist today:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li><em>Epistola ad Joannem Ugljesam<\/em>.\u00a0 Letter of John Ugljesa.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p align=\"justify\">The oration on the theotokos recapitulates all his theological doctrine, and has been supposed to be the last work by our author.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">The main manuscript\u00a0used by Sotiropolous for the <em>Five orations on the light of Tabor<\/em> is BNF Paris gr. 1294 (P), which is online.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_4_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_4_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"https:\/\/archivesetmanuscrits.bnf.fr\/ark:\/12148\/cc213184\">4<\/a><\/sup>\u00a0 It also contains two of the pastoral letters.<\/p>\n<p><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2019\/05\/paris_gr_1249_fol26_theophanes_light_of_tabor-1.png\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"aligncenter wp-image-19226 size-full\" src=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2019\/05\/paris_gr_1249_fol26_theophanes_light_of_tabor-1.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1278\" height=\"731\" \/><\/a><\/p>\n<p>Here is a limited bibliography.\u00a0 The reader should start with Polemis&#8217; monograph on the subject.<\/p>\n<p><span style=\"text-decoration: underline;\">Editions:<\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">\u03a7\u03b1\u03c1\u03b1\u03bb. \u0393. \u03a3\u03c9\u03c4\u03b7\u03c1\u03bf\u03c0\u03bf\u03cd\u03bb\u03bf\u03c5, <em>\u0398\u03b5\u03bf\u03c6\u03ac\u03bd\u03bf\u03c5\u03c2 \u0393\u0384 <\/em><em>\u1f10\u03c0\u03b9\u03c3\u03ba\u03cc\u03c0\u03bf\u03c5 \u039d\u03b9\u03ba\u03b1\u03af\u03b1\u03c2, \u03a0\u03b5\u03c1<\/em><em>\u1f76 \u03b8\u03b1\u03b2\u03c9\u03c1\u03af\u03bf\u03c5 \u03c6\u03c9\u03c4\u03cc\u03c2 \u03bb\u03cc\u03b3\u03bf\u03b9 \u03c0\u03ad\u03bd\u03c4\u03b5<\/em>, Ath\u00e8nes 1990. (= Ch. Sotiropoulos, <em>Theophanes III bishop of Nicaea, On the Light of Tabor, five books<\/em>).\u00a0 I have been quite unable to locate any copies of this, other than one in Athens in the National Library, and one in Bonn in Germany.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">Geo\u0304rgiou Th. Zacharopoulou, <em>Theophane\u0304s Nikaias (? &#8211; +\/- 1380\/1) : ho vios kai to syngraphiko tou ergo<\/em>. Series: Vyzantina keimena kai meletai ; 35. Thessalonike\u0304 : Kentro Vyzantino\u0304n Ereuno\u0304n 2003. ISBN 9607856120. This contains an edition of the Orations on the Light of Tabor, and probably much else.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_5_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_5_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"This contains a two-page summary in French from which the majority of the information above has been taken.\">5<\/a><\/sup>\u00a0 Amusingly the editor disparages earlier editions in the way traditional with new editors, in order to promote his own new and improved one.\u00a0 Infuriatingly he does not print the page numbers of the <em>editio princeps<\/em>, rendering the readily-available volume less than useful.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">The <em>Epistolae III<\/em> are printed in the PG vol. 150, cols 287-349.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">The <em>oratio eucharistica<\/em> is in PG 150, 352-356.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">I\u014dann\u0113s D. Polem\u0113s<em>, Theophanous Nikaias, Apodeixis hoti edynato ex a\u00efdiou gegen\u0113sthai ta onta kai anatrop\u0113 taut\u0113s.<\/em> Editio princeps. Ath\u0113na: Akad\u0113mia Ath\u0113n\u014dn ; J. Vrin [distributor] ; Ousia [distributor] 2000.\u00a0 This is the treatise that beings are not eternal.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">Martin Jugie, <em>Theophanes Nicaenus, Sermo in Sanctissimam Deiparam<\/em>, Romae : Facultas Theologica Pontificii Aethenaei Seminarii Romani, 1935. Greek text and Latin translation.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\"><span style=\"text-decoration: underline;\">Studies:<\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">Ioannis D. Polemis, <em>Theophanes of Nicaea: His Life and Works<\/em>, Series: Wiener Byzantinistische Studien , Volume: 20. Vienna: 1996. ISBN13: 978-3-7001-2227-2.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_6_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_6_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"Publisher website: https:\/\/verlag.oeaw.ac.at\/theophanes-of-nicaea-his-life-and-works\">6<\/a><\/sup> Revision of 1991 Oxford DPhil Thesis supervised by Cyril Mango.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_7_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_7_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"https:\/\/www.history.ac.uk\/history-online\/theses\/thesis\/theophanes-nicaea-his-life-and-work\">7<\/a><\/sup> Includes an appendix of corrections to the Sotiropoulos text.\u00a0 Polemis discusses all the works known to him, printed and otherwise, that the author was able to find, and the manuscripts for them all.\u00a0 The standard monograph.<\/p>\n<p align=\"justify\">Stephan, Christian, \u201cTheophanes III of Nicea\u201d, in: <em>Religion Past and Present. Encyclopedia of Theology and Religion<\/em>. Brill: 2006-13. ISBN: 9789004146662.<sup><a href=\"#footnote_8_19222\" id=\"awef_ident_8_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"Online version: http:\/\/dx.doi.org\/10.1163\/1877-5888_rpp_SIM_026024\">8<\/a><\/sup><\/p>\n\t\t\t<style>\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\tol.footnotes.awepost_19222>li {list-style-type:decimal;}\n\t\t\t\tol.footnotes.awepost_19222>li>span.symbol {display: none;}\n\t\t\tol.footnotes { color:#666666; }\r\nol.footnotes li { font-size:80%; }\t\t\t<\/style>\n\t\t\t<ol start=\"1\" class=\"footnotes awepost_19222\">\n\t<li id=\"footnote_1_19222\" class=\"footnote\"> <a href=\"https:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Tabor_Light\">https:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Tabor_Light<\/a>. The reference given is \u201cIoann\u0113s Polem\u0113s, Theophanes of Nicaea: His Life and Works, vol. 20 (Verlag der \u00d6sterreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1996), p. 99\u201d.<span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_1_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_2_19222\" class=\"footnote\">Polemis p.99: \u201cThe view that the light of God&#8217;s glory is identical with the fire of hell is quite common among the Greek Fathers and can be traced back to Gregory of Nazianzos, who affirms in a passage quoted by Theophanes without acknowledgment that the punishment of sinners will be \u1f61\u03c2 \u03c0\u1fe6\u03c1 \u1f30\u03b4\u03b5\u1fd6\u03bd, \u1f45\u03bd \u1f61\u03c2 \u03c6\u1ff6\u03c2 \u03bf\u1f50\u03ba \u1f10\u03b3\u03bd\u1f7d\u03c1\u03b9\u03c3\u03b1\u03bd\u201d (\u201cseeing Him to be fire whom he did not recognise as light\u201d), and n. 109: \u201cGregory of Nazianzus <em>In laudem Athanasii<\/em>, <em>PG<\/em> 35, 1084D,\u201d i.e. the funeral oration for Athanasius, <em>oratio XXI<\/em>, chapter 2. English translation http:\/\/www.tertullian.org\/fathers2\/NPNF2-07\/Npnf2-07-40.htm#P4015_1195110 <span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_2_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_3_19222\" class=\"footnote\">See review of Polemis at <a href=\"https:\/\/www.persee.fr\/doc\/rebyz_0766-5598_1997_num_55_1_1946_t1_0348_0000_3\">https:\/\/www.persee.fr\/doc\/rebyz_0766-5598_1997_num_55_1_1946_t1_0348_0000_3<\/a><span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_3_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_4_19222\" class=\"footnote\"><a href=\"https:\/\/archivesetmanuscrits.bnf.fr\/ark:\/12148\/cc213184\">https:\/\/archivesetmanuscrits.bnf.fr\/ark:\/12148\/cc213184<\/a><span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_4_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_5_19222\" class=\"footnote\">This contains a two-page summary in French from which the majority of the information above has been taken.<span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_5_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_6_19222\" class=\"footnote\">Publisher website: <a href=\"https:\/\/verlag.oeaw.ac.at\/theophanes-of-nicaea-his-life-and-works\">https:\/\/verlag.oeaw.ac.at\/theophanes-of-nicaea-his-life-and-works<\/a><span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_6_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_7_19222\" class=\"footnote\"> <a href=\"https:\/\/www.history.ac.uk\/history-online\/theses\/thesis\/theophanes-nicaea-his-life-and-work\">https:\/\/www.history.ac.uk\/history-online\/theses\/thesis\/theophanes-nicaea-his-life-and-work<\/a><span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_7_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_8_19222\" class=\"footnote\">Online version: http:\/\/dx.doi.org\/10.1163\/1877-5888_rpp_SIM_026024<span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\"><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">[<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/2019\/05\/29\/theophanes-iii-of-nicaea-and-the-light-of-god-as-the-fire-of-hell-for-those-who-reject-him\/#awef_ident_8_19222\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\"  title=\"Jump back to text\"  aria-labelby=\"Jump back to text\">\u21a9<\/a><span class=\"awef-pre-backlink\">]<\/span><\/span><\/li><\/ol>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>The Wikipedia article on the \u201cLight of Tabor\u201d &#8211; the divine light seen by the disciples on Mount Tabor \u2013 mentions that \u201cTheophanes of Nicaea\u201d believed that \u201cthe <\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"advanced_seo_description":"","jetpack_seo_html_title":"","jetpack_seo_noindex":false,"jetpack_seo_schema_type":"","_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"_awef_post_faq_schema":[],"_jetpack_hide_featured_image":false,"_jetpack_featured_image_duplicate_dismissed":0,"_jetpack_feature_clip_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[19],"tags":[1646,1647],"class_list":["post-19222","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-from-my-diary-announcements","tag-theophanes-of-nicaea","tag-theophanes-of-nicea"],"jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/19222","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=19222"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/19222\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=19222"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=19222"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/roger-pearse.com\/weblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=19222"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}